My friend and I loved our Fang sandwiches! Big slab of meatloaf with fresh and tasty additions. Also, the service was friendly and we got our food fast. Unfortunately, the only seating is outside and mostly not in the shade. There were three tables with only one was in the shade and that one was taken so we had to eat lunch under the blazing hot sun at noon time. I went back to my car for my sunglasses and sun hat but it was still uncomfortable.

My God was this good food! When we saw that they were ranked by Yelp as the best sandwich shop in Ohio, we knew we needed to go... STAT! The restaurant is run by a husband and wife duo. They were in the restaurant, cooking up the delicious food when we went. The guy behind the register was very friendly and helped with all the recommendations. They even brought our food out to us since we sat outside, it was such a beautiful day. Everything is very casual, but really fun 10 out of 10 would recommend!!!

Everything we have tried here has been amazing. Ordered online. Was ready when promised.

Everything went well! We stopped by for lunch after visiting a couple local estate sales. The service was friendly and fast. It was a simple ordering process with a board out front and a hand held menu as well. This is not a sit down restaurant, primarily takeout but there is some seating outside. It was a sunny day (yay!) in Ohio so we sat outside. Our two sandwiches were amazing. I had the Bella Donna and my husband had Lucifer's Hammer. We also had some of the dill potato salad as well as the Carolina Kettle chips. My sandwich was a grilled portobello with roasted red pepper and cheese. The fang sauce is wonderful and has a great flavor. The potato salad has just the right amount of dill and the chips were unique too as the were salt and balsamic vinegar. Overall very good place for a sandwich and we will return for more great options when we return to the area.

When I say that their Shipyard Tuna Melt is the best tuna melt I've ever had, I'm not lying. Maybe even the best sandwich--or best lunch I've ever eaten. I moved away from Columbus about a year ago and this sandwich is still on my mind. That's how good it is. Tuna salad, mayo, dijon, mustard, pickles, and melted white cheddar on marbled rye. My mouth is watering as I type this. The only thing that made it better was an order of spicy Carolina Kettle potato chips on the side, along with Cheerwine, a cherry soda that tastes like a Shirley Temple. You haunt my dreams in the best way possible, Newfangled Kitchen!!!

I kind of hate to let people know how great this place is because it's already so busy! However, I've been here twice and it is just so much better than the two top sandwich places in German Village that I have to give them a five star review and encourage them to keep doing what they're doing! I've had the meatloaf and they were both just delicious. Also, the staff is always very friendly.

I was finally able to visit this nice deli spot in Bexley. I actually drove right past it the first time. Parked at Market District and walked over. I ordered the shipyard tuna melt and chocolate kettle cookie, to-go. I bought the last cookie. The staff were nice while taking my order. The sandwich was good. Cookie was ok. I like the concept of sweet & salty. It's just the chips on it wasn't as crunchy. I certainly got my tuna fix. This is a rather late review. One I forgot to post. I can imagine this being a nice place to dine outside in the warmer months. I'd try it again.

We decided to order lunch today . We decided to order from this restaurant I've had food from here before but it's been a while. We were not disappointed the food is fresh nicely portioned and delicious .

Fantastic to go order. The meatloaf is absolutely fantastic. This will not be the last time I place this order.

Great sandwiches, quick service. Smells are free. No dine in, but they do have picnic tables outside if the weather is amenable. We got a Reuben, Meatloaf sandwich, and potato salad and it was all delicious! The FANG sauce surprised me. Yum!